You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Creation of a workflow for chat workflows that allows for socratic dialogue between a user and an LLM with a moderator LLM.
Creation of a workflow that allows for socratic dialogue between two LLMs and a human moderator.
Creation of a workflow that allows for socratic dialogue between two LLMs and an LLM moderator.
<sup>Originally posted by **TomLucidor** January 22, 2025</sup>
Some criteria for Socratic Dialogue:
- Having chatbots of opposite sides read media with their own bias/preference using document RAGs and web-crawling tools
- Making a third moderator agent that prevents self-contradiction or incoherence by either side
- Converging conversation such that compromise can be reached, or all arguments have been exhausted
- Recording major arguments into PKM tools such that they can be recapped
- Goalpost-moving and concession-making should be an optional feature
Possible reference:
- https://github.com/RunzheYang/SocraticAI
- https://github.com/GiovanniGatti/socratic-llm</div>
My response:
I think the best way to implement it would be through the chat workflows functionality, as it allows for a structured dialogue, turn-by-turn, and with a little tweaking could be extended to support answering by an LLM, so that a user may select a customized workflow, user enters a topic/question, and then the question/topic is discussed by the LLM with the user or with another LLM. It should also be possible to specify in the workflow configuration file that a third party LLM is used after every discussion round for moderation.
The question of 'enough' is a little harder though.
Moving chats into a PKM would line up with aforementioned syncing with Obsidian.
Goalposts and concessions could be handled through the moderator's instructions in the workflow configuration.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Title.
Creation of a workflow for chat workflows that allows for socratic dialogue between a user and an LLM with a moderator LLM.
Creation of a workflow that allows for socratic dialogue between two LLMs and a human moderator.
Creation of a workflow that allows for socratic dialogue between two LLMs and an LLM moderator.
Original discussion: #496
My response:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: